A Practical Guide to Finding and Evaluating Cyber Insurance for Your LLC

Good Morning!

1. Feature: A Practical Guide to Finding and Evaluating Cyber Insurance for Your LLC (5 min read)

2. What You Might’ve Missed From The Archive:

   • How to Hire Subcontractors Without Getting Burned: 9 Golden Rules

   • The One Factor That Determines Your Business Success​

   • Like You Mean Business: Your LLC’s Credit Blueprint

Thursday has arrived, close out the week strong!

-TCoL

Missed our last feature article? Don’t Call Them a Co-Founder Just Yet 
Read it here.

Want to streamline your business operations and save time? With The Co. Letter Premium, you get instant access to a growing library of professional templates. All for just $7.95 per month—less than your usual Starbucks order. Stay in control of your cash flow and protect your business.
[Get Premium Now]

Be smart. Save money. Use TCoL templates.

As a small or medium business (SMB) owner, you’re facing everything from supply chain snarls to digital marketing pivots. But there’s one risk many overlook until it’s too late: cybersecurity. According to the latest industry data, 43% of cyberattacks now target SMBs. Yet just 17% carry cyber insurance.

That gap could cost you dearly. A single breach—ransomware, phishing, or worse—can run your company between $100,000 and $1.25 million in financial and reputational damage.

Cyber insurance helps offset those risks. Whether purchased as a standalone policy or as a rider to an existing plan, it’s fast becoming a must-have, not a nice-to-have. This guide walks you through the essentials: how policies are priced, what to look for in coverage, how to spot hidden exclusions, and how to prep for a conversation with your broker or carrier.

We also list three providers known for SMB cyber coverage to help you kick off your search.

Understanding Cyber Insurance: The Basics

Cyber insurance protects your LLC from losses due to cyber incidents like data breaches, ransomware attacks, or social engineering fraud. It’s not the same as general liability insurance, which covers physical harm. Cyber insurance covers digital fallout.

Policies generally take two forms:

• Standalone Policies: These offer broad coverage, including legal defense, data restoration, and lost income. Ideal for high-risk LLCs such as healthcare or e-commerce.

• Add-On Riders: These bolt onto broader business policies like a BOP. They’re usually cheaper and work for low-risk LLCs that handle minimal customer data.

Before you begin shopping, ask:

• Do we store personal info like emails, card data, or SSNs?

• Do we rely on third-party software or cloud vendors?

• Are we regulated under HIPAA, PCI-DSS, or GDPR?

These factors shape your risk profile and what kind of policy you’ll need.

How Cyber Insurance Policies Are Priced

SMB cyber insurance premiums typically run between $500 and $7,500 per year, with a median cost near $1,740. Final pricing depends on several key factors:

• Revenue: Some providers charge by revenue volume. For example, a provider may quote between $3–$7 per $1,000 in revenue. An LLC generating $900,000 might pay $6,300 annually for a $2 million policy.

• Industry Risk: Sectors like healthcare, finance, and retail face higher premiums due to their exposure. Healthcare firms, for instance, often pay 20–30% more than professional services.

• Cybersecurity Measures: If your LLC uses multi-factor authentication, endpoint detection, and regular backups, you could earn a 10–15% discount.

• Claims History: A clean slate may drop premiums 5–10%. Prior incidents do the opposite.

• Policy Terms: Coverage limits ($1M–$5M) and deductibles ($2,500–$10,000) affect pricing. Higher coverage means higher cost. Higher deductibles lower the premium but increase your out-of-pocket risk.

• Data Volume: Companies managing tens of thousands of records will see higher costs due to increased breach impact.

What to expect by risk level:

• Low-Risk (e.g., consultants with basic cybersecurity): $500–$1,500/year for $1M coverage.

• Medium-Risk (e.g., retail with moderate data): $1,740–$3,500/year for $1M–$2M.

• High-Risk (e.g., healthcare or tech, sensitive data): $5,000–$7,500/year for $2M–$5M.

Premiums have stabilized heading into 2025, with some businesses seeing modest rate cuts due to increased market competition. To save more, consider bundling cyber coverage with other policies like tech E&O or paying premiums annually.

What to Look for in a Strong Cyber Policy

A quality cyber insurance policy balances affordability with strong protection. Look for these key components:

First-Party Coverage (Protects Your Business)

• Data Breach Response: Covers costs like customer notification, credit monitoring, and public relations.

• Business Interruption: Reimburses lost income and extra costs caused by network outages. Look for policies with waiting periods under 12 hours.

• Ransomware and Cyber Extortion: Pays for ransom demands and recovery.

• Data Restoration: Funds to recover corrupted or deleted data.

Third-Party Coverage (Covers Legal Exposure)

• Legal Defense and Settlements: If you’re sued for mishandling customer data.

• Regulatory Fines: Helps cover penalties from HIPAA or GDPR violations.

• Vendor Breaches: Covers your exposure when third-party vendors are hacked. These are involved in 41% of breaches.

Bonus Features to Prioritize

• Incident Response Services: Access to forensic experts, breach coaches, and PR teams.

• Customizable Options: Look for prior acts coverage and protection against social engineering fraud.

• Clear Terms: Policies should clearly define sublimits, exclusions, and covered events to avoid disputes.

Exclusions to Watch Out For

Even good policies can hide “exclusion” traps. Key exclusions to investigate:

• Nation-State Attacks: Some policies exclude cyberattacks linked to foreign governments. (Example: Merck’s NotPetya claim was initially denied for this reason.) Ask how your carrier defines "war exclusions."

• Employee Errors or Intentional Acts: Phishing errors or rogue employees are common attack vectors. Ensure your policy covers accidental breaches.

• Third-Party System Failures: If your cloud provider fails, some policies won’t pay unless you have dependent system failure coverage.

• Prior Known Risks: Policies may exclude breaches stemming from known vulnerabilities. It pays to conduct a cybersecurity audit before buying.

• Low Sublimits & Long Time Deductibles: A $50,000 sublimit on ransomware won’t go far. Push for higher caps and shorter wait times.

Pro Tip: Have your insurance broker review exclusions carefully and answer all your exclusion questions, including the bullets above. Over 30% of breach-related claims face partial or full denial due to unclear or restrictive policy exclusions and terms.

Preparing to Meet Your Broker or Search Online

Whether you go direct or work through an agent or broker, come prepared:

• Assess Your Risk Profile: List the types of data you hold, security controls in place, and any past incidents.

• Get Your Financials in Order: Revenue, headcount, and software used are basic inputs for quotes.

• Tighten Security First: Adding MFA, employee training, or antivirus tools can cut your premium or expand eligibility.

• Request Multiple Quotes: Start 4–6 months ahead of renewal and compare policies carefully.

• Ask Sharp Questions: Get clarity on ransomware caps, vendor coverage, sublimits, waiting periods, and the claims process.

Three Providers to Start With

Here are three respected names in SMB cyber insurance. We don’t endorse or earn from these suggestions—they’re simply good launch points:

• Chubb: Offers customizable standalone policies with global reach. Includes incident response services but may have strict underwriting.

• Travelers: Provides both riders and standalone policies. Offers HIPAA compliance guidance and breach-prevention resources. Requires agent involvement.

• Coalition: A tech-forward option with real-time threat monitoring. Best for digital-savvy teams, though pricing can run higher in high-risk sectors.

You might also check aggregators like CyberPolicy for more options.

Final Thoughts

Cyber insurance is no longer a luxury—it’s a safety net. As SMBs grow more digital, the risk of attack increases. This guide gives you the knowledge to shop smart, ask the right questions, and sidestep the most common traps.

Start by reviewing your risks. Shore up your digital defenses. Then talk with a broker or request a few quotes online. The peace of mind you gain far outweighs the premium.

For more information, visit the Cyber Readiness Institute or the FTC's small business cybersecurity page.

Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!