Good morning!

-TCoL

Missed our last feature article? Getting Your Business on Wikipedia

Global hiring is changing fast. From AI's impact on HR to evolving compliance requirements and international expansion strategies, the rules are constantly shifting.

Oyster's events bring together HR leaders, founders, operators, and global employment experts to discuss what's working now—and what's coming next.

Whether you're hiring internationally today or planning for tomorrow, you'll walk away with practical insights you can actually use.

Explore Hiring Events

Yes, but it is harder to prove than most warnings suggest, and one of the arguments you might have heard typically does not work in Florida.

Veil piercing is governed by state law and the elements differ from state to state. We are using Florida because an article like this has to pick one and a large share of our subscribers are Florida-based. Elsewhere, the concerns will be similar, but the particulars might not match.

When a Florida case reaches a jury on this question, the judge reads the current standard jury instruction, numbered 416.43. We are using that jury instruction as our guide rather than working through the appellate decisions behind it. A Florida civil jury is made of residents, none of them lawyers (typically), and the instruction has to be understood by all. That makes it the plainest statement of what your adversary must establish to reach past your company and go after your personal assets. However, underneath it sits a deep body of case law that turns on the facts of each dispute.

The person suing you is usually a creditor the company cannot pay, and that person has to prove three separate things to pierce the protection your LLC or corporation provides.

First, that you dominated and controlled the company to the point that its separate identity was not sufficiently maintained and it lacked an existence independent from you. Money moving between your accounts and the company’s is evidence for this element, as is the company paying your personal bills.

Second, that the company was formed or used for a fraudulent or improper purpose. This is a separate hurdle, not a conclusion drawn from the first one. In Dania Jai-Alai Palace, Inc. v. Sykes, the Florida Supreme Court said that the veil cannot be pierced without a showing of improper conduct. The Court also repeated a rule that Florida courts had applied for decades: the mere fact that one or two individuals own and control the stock structure of a corporation does not lead inevitably to the conclusion that the entity is a fraud or the alter ego of its owners. Running a small company you personally control does not, standing alone, create personal liability for you.

Third, that the person suing was harmed by the fraudulent or improper formation or use of the company.

The instruction says corporate veil, and the doctrine evolved around corporations. Florida courts have applied it to limited liability companies, and the notes to the jury instruction cite Houri v. Boaziz as an example. Those notes say case law appears to apply the doctrine to other business entities (like LLCs), which is softer than saying it does.

Florida Statutes, section 605.0304 starts from the position that a debt of a limited liability company is solely the company’s, and that you are not personally liable for it by reason of being or acting as a member or manager. The statute also says that the failure of an LLC to observe formalities relating to the exercise of its powers or the management of its activities and affairs is not a ground for imposing personal liability on a member or manager. Missing minutes and thin governance records are not, by themselves, the argument against a Florida LLC owner.

Do not read that as permission to run a sloppy company. The statute does nothing about whether your money stayed separate from the company’s, which is still in play under the first jury instruction element, and it does nothing about the other places your records get examined. Courts look closely at how a company was run and documented whenever ownership, authority, or a transfer of assets is disputed, and the IRS looks at the same records when it tests whether transactions between a company and its owners are what the company says they are. Your records are also your own evidence: when someone argues your company had no separate existence, the minutes, the resolutions, and the ledger are what you put in front of them.

Someone with real evidence on the second jury instruction element will use every loose fact about the company’s operations to build the first one, and these cases turn on details that do not fit in a newsletter article. If anything about how you run your company gives you pause, take it to your attorney now rather than after you get sued. If you don’t have a lawyer, our earlier piece, Need an Attorney for your Business? A Guide to Selecting Carefully, walks through how to choose.

Everything above concerns liability a court imposes on you. A personal guarantee is voluntarily, and it puts your personal assets at risk to support your company’s debt. No one has to prove domination, improper purpose, or harm if you signed a personal guarantee. Our earlier piece, The Personal Guarantee You Probably Signed Without Reading, covers what that signature does.

The jury instruction is clear and short. Pull it up, take the three elements one at a time, and write down what someone suing you could put under each. If you have concerns, call your attorney and carefully resolve any issues with their assistance.

The Co. Letter provides general information, not legal advice, and reading it creates no attorney-client relationship. Veil piercing is fact specific, outcomes vary by case, and the law differs from state to state. Consult a licensed attorney about your own company.

Question:

Can a single member LLC be converted into a multi-member LLC?

Answer:

Thank you for writing. We are reading your question as adding an owner to an LLC you already have, not a statutory conversion into a different type of entity, and we are assuming your LLC has been taxed the default way: as a disregarded entity reported on Schedule C of your individual tax return. If you elected S corporation treatment somewhere along the way, most of what follows below changes, and that is a conversation for your CPA before anything else happens.

Back to the question: the short answer is yes, and the documents are the easy part.

Start with a written resolution admitting the new member and issuing the membership interest, signed and dated by the existing member. Record the interest in a membership interest ledger so the percentages of ownership are properly documented. Our earlier piece, Your LLC Membership Interest Ledger, shows what that record should contain.

Then adopt a multi-member operating agreement. If you have one now, it was written for a company with one decision maker, and the replacement has to set who makes decisions, how profits are split, who can bind the company, what happens when one of you wants out, and how a deadlock breaks. Our earlier piece, Your LLC Is Missing Its Most Important Document, covers the basics and will get you started.

Before any money changes hands, decide how the new member comes in, because that choice sets the tax bill. If they buy part of your interest and pay you personally, the IRS treats the deal as a sale of a share of the company’s assets, and you can owe tax on the gain even though the business never changed hands. If instead they contribute cash or property to the company in exchange for their interest, the contribution is generally tax free to both of you. Debt on the company’s books can change that, so have your CPA analyze the tax consequences if your company has an outstanding loan.

A third route is common when the new member is a key employee. If they receive an ownership stake instead of paying for one, that stake is compensation, and they owe income tax on its value in the year they receive it. A profits interest, which gives them a share of future growth rather than a piece of what the company is worth today, usually avoids that result.

Once the second member arrives, your LLC becomes a partnership for federal tax purposes. That means a chart of accounts carrying a separate capital account for each of you, tracking what each one contributed, each share of profit and loss, and each distribution. Year one also splits in two. Your Schedule C covers the business up to the day the new member is admitted, and the partnership return covers the rest.

The partnership files Form 1065 and issues a K-1 to each member. It is due the fifteenth day of the third month after your year ends, which on a calendar year puts it a month ahead of your personal return, and the late filing penalty runs per partner for each month the return sits unfiled, up to twelve months, whether or not the company earned anything.

Ask your CPA whether the company needs a new EIN. A single-member LLC is a sole proprietorship for income tax purposes, and the IRS tells a sole proprietor who takes in partners to get a new number, but the published guidance does not squarely address an LLC that keeps its state identity and adds an owner. Practitioners land on both sides. The answer affects your payroll accounts and your bank, so settle it before the first filing.

Tell your bank. It will want the resolution, the new operating agreement, and updated signature authority on the account. Your leases, loans, and licenses may also carry change-of-ownership language that requires notice or consent before the new member signs.

Take the resolution, the draft operating agreement, and the buy-in structure to your attorney and your CPA together, before anyone signs. The documents can be amended later; the structure of the buy-in cannot.

The Co. Letter is not your attorney or your accountant. This column is general information, not legal or tax advice, and reading it creates no attorney-client relationship. Tax treatment depends on facts specific to your company. Consult a licensed attorney and a CPA before adding a member to your LLC.

Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!