Rethinking Your Holiday Bonuses

You are not alone in the yearly struggle to be thoughtful and creative.

Good Morning!

  1. Feature: Rethinking Your Holiday Bonuses (4 min)

  2. From the Archive:

  3. Dear TCoL: I Need Trustworthy Help with Quickbooks

-TCoL

Year after year, most small business owners think holiday bonuses mean cash or gift cards. That works, but it is also forgettable and easy for employees to compare with a larger employer down the street. An advantage comes from bonuses that tell your people that they matter in ways they can feel and remember long after the tree is gone.

Let’s get thoughtful and creative this year.

Rethink what a bonus really is

A holiday bonus does three jobs at once. It thanks people for the year. It signals what the business values. It quietly markets your culture to anyone who hears about it.

A simple cash amount usually does only the first job. A more creative approach can still respect your budget while building loyalty, referrals, and even future hiring. Many small firms mix a modest financial bonus with one or two personal or experiential rewards, so no one feels short changed.

Decide on design principles before picking ideas

Before choosing any specific idea, decide what result you want most. Some owners want to keep key people from leaving in the new year. Others want to reduce burnout, deepen relationships, or encourage specific behaviors such as learning or sales growth. That primary goal should shape the bonus.

If burnout is high, extra paid time off or simple wellness gifts will land better than a small check. If you need skills to grow, learning focused bonuses make more sense than another party. It also helps to ask some staff what kind of reward they actually value. Then keep expectations clear from year to year so people understand the pattern.

Treat time and energy as a premium gift

The one thing many employees cannot buy on their own is more time. Granting everyone an extra day or two of free time during the year with no meetings and no email beats a forgettable trinket.

Some owners close the business early for a day and pay everyone as usual. Over time this can become a tradition that people plan around each year. Others hand out simple time passes that employees can cash in during the coming year for an extra day off when life is busy, such as the first day of school, tax week, or major family events. The cost is predictable and the goodwill is large.

Get tools that work as hard as you do.

The Co. Letter Premium gives you instant access to a growing library of proven templates designed to help you and your LLC save time, improve cash flow, and protect your business. All are professionally prepared.

Use experiences that create stories

A well-chosen shared experience will be remembered for years and quietly strengthens the bond inside the company. This might be a modest team retreat close to home or a local outing with family invited.

Some owners turn the bonus into a pick your own “experience catalog.” Each person receives a set budget and a menu that might include a cooking class, local sports tickets, a concert, or a simple weekend cabin rental. The key is letting employees choose from a short list that fits their life stage and interests. This option requires a bit more employer effort but can be worth it.

Treat learning and growth as a form of currency

Many people value progress even more than pay. A powerful bonus is a personal development fund that each employee can direct toward a course, certification, or conference in the coming year. The amount does not have to be large to signal belief and trust.

To keep it practical, set simple rules. The learning should relate to their role or to the business. It should be preapproved in writing and used by a clear date. Some owners add a small extra cash reward when someone completes their program and shares one thing they learned with the rest of the team. That turns the bonus into a multiplier.

Support health, family, and everyday life

When money is tight, anything that makes life easier feels like a real gift. Creative examples include a one-time household helper stipend that can be used for cleaning, childcare, or elder care during the holidays. Another approach is a wellness package that covers a few massage sessions, a gym membership, or a basic health check.

You can also offer a “family night on us” bonus. Each person receives a fixed amount to spend on one evening with their family or closest friends.

Connect bonuses to ownership and upside

A holiday bonus can remind your people that they share in the upside, not just the workload. Even if you are not ready for formal equity, you can create a simple profit share pool that pays out at year end based on clear rules.

The actual payout may be modest in the first year. The impact comes from explaining the formula plainly and showing the connection between results and bonus. You quietly teach everyone to think like owners.

Some owners reinforce this with a short owner’s letter in plain language at a holiday meeting. The letter walks through what went right, what hurt, and what the team bonus represents. That habit builds financial literacy as well as trust.

Make recognition feel real, not forced

Many employees care deeply about being seen. A strong complement to any financial bonus is a structured recognition moment that feels thoughtful rather than cheesy.

One method is to ask each manager to write a short, specific note to each person describing one contribution that really mattered this year. Another is a simple in-house award evening where every award is tied to a story rather than a title. The cost is almost nothing, but people keep those notes and stories for years. Done well, this becomes an emotional dividend that helps them stay during hard stretches.

Let employees steer part of the bonus

One way to keep things fresh and fair is to let employees allocate a portion of their own bonus among options. For example, you might split the bonus into three buckets. One bucket is automatic cash. A second bucket can be directed into extra time off, learning, or wellness. A third bucket can go either to a charity of their choice or to a shared cause the team picks together. This approach respects individual differences while keeping administration manageable.

How to put this into action this season

To move from idea to execution:

First, decide what you can comfortably afford in total and lean toward repeatability. A smaller bonus you can repeat each year beats a large bonus you cannot match later.

Second, choose one core financial element and one or two creative elements from the categories above. That keeps your plan easy to explain and easy to repeat.

Third, communicate early and plainly. Tie the bonus directly to your appreciation and to the results the business achieved together.

Over time, your holiday bonus will stop being a simple line item and will become part of the story people tell about your business and working for you.

Dear TCoL: I Need Trustworthy Help with Quickbooks

Question: I really need help with Quickbooks but am very reluctant to try and pick someone off the internet that I don’t know and then give them access to my books, my business checking account and credit card info. What would you suggest?

Answer: We faced the same decision you are now facing. Granting a stranger access to your books, bank accounts, and credit cards is a serious step. The goal is to get qualified help without creating new risks for your business.

Start by deciding what kind of help you actually need. Many owners believe they need full-service bookkeeping when they really need a reliable chart of accounts (tailored to their business) and a few hours of guidance. Others want ongoing bookkeeping but do not need payroll or inventory support. A clear scope protects your budget and keeps you from hiring someone who will do far more than you need.

Once you know the scope, focus on finding someone who comes recommended by people you trust. Ask business owners in your circle who they use and whether that person has been dependable through tax season and the ordinary chaos of a small business. Personal referrals are still the best filter for work this sensitive.

Your CPA is the next best source. Some firms offer QuickBooks support directly. That makes things easy, especially during the transition to tax return preparation. Others maintain short lists of bookkeepers they trust enough to send their own clients to. If your CPA is willing to vouch for a provider, that usually means the provider has produced clean books that hold up during tax prep. That is a standard worth borrowing.

When you speak with any candidate, ask how they protect client financial data. Ask whether they carry professional liability or cyber risk insurance. Professionals who take security seriously will tell you exactly how they work.

If you take your time and work through trusted referrals, you reduce guesswork and avoid the feeling of picking a stranger off the internet. You end up with someone who understands your business and protects it. That is the kind of help worth paying for.

TaxElm: Want to keep more of what you earn? Our tax strategy system helps entrepreneurs and business owners legally reduce their tax burden. Download our free Tax Savings Starter Kit or book a discovery call with Matt Grimmer from our team.

Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!