The New ICE Age: Hiring Compliance Playbook in 2025

Good Morning!

1. Feature: The New ICE Age: Hiring Compliance Playbook in 2025
   (4 min read)

2. From the Archive: Your LLC Is Growing In Other States—Now What About Sales and Income Tax Nexus? Read it here.

Tuesday is a chance to find your rhythm, build momentum, and make real progress toward your goals.

-TCoL

Missed our last feature article? Your LLC’s Essential Online Toolkit: Credibility on a Shoestring. Read it here.

Want to streamline your business operations and save time? With The Co. Letter Premium, you get instant access to a growing library of professional templates. All for just $7.95 per month—less than your usual Starbucks order. Stay in control of your cash flow and protect your business.
[Get Premium Now]

Be smart. Save money. Use TCoL templates.

2025 has become an exceptionally cold year for employers on the immigration-enforcement front. Work-site raids—from Omaha meat-packing plants to Florida construction sites—are in the headlines, and the current administration has publicly directed Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to raise arrests from “a few hundred per day” to at least 1,200–1,500.

For small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) and new LLC owners without an HR department, the surge raises an urgent question: How do I stay compliant in a very fluid regulatory environment?

The playbook below distills a path to survive the “New ICE Age.”

1. Master the I-9 Process

• Use the current form. As of June 30, 2025, the only acceptable edition is Form I-9 dated 01/20/2025 (available at uscis.gov).

• Deadlines matter. Employees must finish Section 1 no later than their first paid day; employers must complete Section 2 within three business days of that start date.

• Document choice and copies. Let employees choose which List A, B, or C documents to present. Copying those documents is optional—but if you copy for one worker you must copy for all to avoid discrimination claims.

• Penalties. Simple paperwork errors now run from $288 to $2,861 per form; knowingly hiring an unauthorized worker can cost from $716 to $28,619 per person after multiple offenses.

• Retention. Keep I-9s for three years after hire or one year after termination—whichever is later—and store them separately from personnel files for quick retrieval.

• Self-audit twice a year. Calendar a 30-minute self-audit every six months to check for missing signatures, expired documents or date errors. Note corrections with today’s date—never back-date.

2. Enroll in E-Verify (Even if Your State Doesn’t Require It)

E-Verify is free at E-Verify.gov and takes about 30 minutes to enroll. Submitting each new hire’s information within three business days demonstrates “good-faith compliance” in any ICE audit.

• Handle mismatches correctly. If a Tentative Non-confirmation (TNC) is issued, you must give the employee a Further Action Notice and allow eight federal working days to start resolving it. Do not suspend, cut hours, or fire them while the TNC is pending.

• Sub-contractors and staffing firms. Where applicable, add a clause to vendor contracts requiring them to use E-Verify or to maintain compliant I-9s—and ask for an annual certification.

3. Prepare for an ICE Visit

Work-site operations often begin without warning and can paralyze daily operations. A January 2025 raid on a Newark auto-repair shop—in which local news reported that even U.S. citizens were briefly detained—illustrated what happens when staff are caught off guard.

• One-page response plan. List (a) your designated ICE point-of-contact and backup, (b) where I-9s are stored, and (c) your lawyer’s phone number. Post a laminated copy near reception.

• Warrants 101. Forms I-200 (arrest warrant) and I-205 (removal order) target people, not premises. They do not necessarily authorize ICE to enter private areas. Only a judicial search warrant signed by a judge permits access beyond areas open to the public.

• Document the encounter. If local law allows, record video or take notes (names, badge numbers, time in/out, items seized) and back the file up to the cloud.

• Legal call-tree. The moment agents arrive—or you receive a Notice of Inspection, which gives three business days to produce I-9s—alert legal counsel.

4. Stay on Top of Policy Changes

Immigration rules change faster than weather apps refresh. For example:

• TPS cliffhangers. Venezuela currently has two overlapping Temporary Protected Status (TPS) designations: one expiring April 2 2025, the other September 10 2025. DHS must decide on renewals roughly 60 days before each date; failure to extend could invalidate many employees’ work authorization overnight.

• Humanitarian-parole reversals. Parole programs covering Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans and Venezuelans were scaled back in early 2025, adding uncertainty for industries that rely on seasonal labor.

• Free alerts. Subscribe to USCIS bulletins and the non-profit Immigration Policy Tracking Project for real-time updates.

5. Support and Retain Your Workforce

Fear of enforcement drives absenteeism and turnover. Pro-active support keeps teams intact.

• Know-Your-Rights sessions. Pay or partner with an immigration law firm to deliver a 30-minute training (English and Spanish). Pay employees for the time if possible.

• Resource handouts. Download bilingual flyers from the National Immigration Law Center and post them alongside the federal labor-law posters.

• Transparent communication. An audit notice does not mean firings; reassure staff without making promises you can’t keep (like, “we’ll get you a visa”).

• Avoid obstruction. Do not destroy records, hide employees, or lie to agents—such actions can bring criminal obstruction charges.

Key Takeaways

1. Forms first. Using the 01/20/2025 Form I-9 correctly—every time—is your safest firewall.

2. Automate compliance. E-Verify costs $0; mistakes cost thousands.

3. Plan, drill, repeat. A one-page ICE plan plus bi-annual self-audits beat panic every time.

4. Lead with empathy. A supported workforce is a productive one, even in a blizzard of enforcement.

Next Steps for Readers

Bottom line: Preparation is your warmest defense against the chill of enforcement. Implement these simple, low-cost steps now, and you can keep hiring—and growing.

Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!