Good morning!

-TCoL

Missed our last feature article? Don’t Skip Meeting Minutes

Tomorrow is the day before a federal holiday, with a long weekend waiting behind it. You already have a sense of how the morning will go. There is probably an employee or two whose name you could almost say out loud before the phone rings, the sort who comes down with something to turn a three-day weekend into four days off. A handful of days a year land like this, and you can feel each one coming from a week away.

Here is the problem with that feeling. That call could be a real illness, an appointment someone kept to themselves, an absence the law protects, or a plain long-weekend fib, and you cannot tell which from a hunch. The law cares a great deal about which one it is. So, the answer is not to catch the person. It is to build a structure that makes the questionable day cost something, plan for the days you can predict, and keep each decision on ground you could defend out loud.

Start with one pool of paid time off. Instead of a bank of sick days sitting next to a separate bank of vacation days, give your people a single account they draw on for anything. When sick time and vacation come out of the same place, a questionable Thursday is no longer free; it spends a day they were saving for the beach in August. The structure does the discouraging for you, without singling anyone out or asking for a doctor's note over a runny nose.

One caution before you rewrite your employee handbook: in the roughly twenty states, plus Washington, D.C., that require paid sick leave, a combined policy still has to meet that floor, which can dictate how the time accrues, what you may ask for, and how unused days carry over. In many states, like Florida, there is no such mandate at all, leaving you free to combine sick time and vacation into a single pool. However, always confirm your state's rule and talk to your employment lawyer before you consolidate.

Then put the call-in procedure in writing and require a live conversation. An employee who has to reach a supervisor and say it out loud thinks twice in a way that a text or a groggy voicemail never asks of them. Spell out how much notice you expect when the need is foreseeable, who they have to reach, and what a no-call absence costs, then apply it to everyone the same way. Write it into the handbook and have people sign that they read it.

Because you can see these days coming, staff for them instead of bracing for them. If the day before a holiday reliably runs short, schedule a lighter day, offer the shift as premium time to the people who want the hours, or line up a floater in advance. A spike you have planned for is an inconvenience; a spike you ignored until seven in the morning is a crisis, and the difference is a few minutes of thought and planning the week before.

Give people an honest way to get the time, too, and fewer will invent a reason to take it. Much last-minute absence is not illness at all; it is a personal errand or a run of burnout with no clean way to ask. A floating personal day, or reasonable room to shift hours when the work allows, lets someone take a Friday off without a story. Owners who loosen a rigid policy often find the phantom Fridays decrease on their own.

When one person's pattern still stands out, talk to them before you assume anything. Sit down and ask them directly whether something is going on. You may learn about a childcare gap you can solve with a schedule change, a sick relative, or a health issue you knew nothing about. Or, you may discover, they are simply not dedicated to their job.

Before you dock pay or write anyone up, know the rules. If you employ fifty or more people, the Family and Medical Leave Act may apply. It protects eligible workers, meaning those who have worked for you at least a year, logged at least 1,250 hours in the prior twelve months, and are based at a site with fifty or more employees within seventy-five miles. Those workers can take up to twelve weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave for a serious health condition, their job and group health coverage stay in place, and a qualifying absence cannot be held against them.

If you employ fifteen or more, the Americans with Disabilities Act can require you to bend an attendance policy as a reasonable accommodation unless doing so is an undue hardship, which may mean a modified schedule or extra unpaid time beyond your normal limit.

In the states that mandate paid sick leave, disciplining someone for using protected time is its own violation, often a costlier one than the absence you were worried about, and the rule that governs is the one where your employee works, not where your business is based.

None of this leaves you stuck with the pattern. It means you act on the pattern and the policy, applied across the board, and never on a hunch aimed at one name. Set the pool, the procedure, and line up additional staff before the next long weekend rather than after. Do that, and tomorrow's call is just a day off, counted the same for everyone, and you never have to decide who was really sick.

The Co. Letter shares general information to help you run your business and is not legal advice. Employment and leave laws differ by state and change often, so confirm the rules where your employees work and talk with an employment attorney before you change a policy or discipline an employee.

Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!