Transferring Highly Appreciated Assets Like Bitcoin and Art to a Sole-Member LLC

Good Morning!

1. Feature: Transferring Highly Appreciated Assets Like Bitcoin and Art to a Sole-Member LLC (5 min read)

2. Dear TCoL: Trying And Not Succeeding To Involve My Son In The Family Business (2 min read)

3. From the Archive: How to Get an SBA Loan in 2025—Even With Tougher Rules. Read it here.

Enjoy your Sunday recharge!

-TCoL

Missed our last feature article? How To Assign Your LLC Ownership Interest To Your Revocable Trust. Read it here.

☕ Protect Your Business for Less Than Your Starbucks Run.
For just $7.95/month, unlock The Co. Letter Premium and get immediate access to our expanding library of professional business templates [Get Premium Now].

Save time. Save money. Stay protected.

The Rise of Bitcoin, Art, and Collector Cars

From late 2022 to mid-2025, Bitcoin has rebounded from under $17,000 to over $100,000+, driven by institutional adoption, regulatory clarity, and inflation hedging. Global art sales hit $14.9 billion in 2024, buoyed by demand for blue-chip and emerging artists. Classic cars also accelerated, with Hagerty reporting a 12% average increase in 2024. These assets now represent significant wealth for many individuals—but their rising value also brings new risks: lawsuits, estate complications, and significant tax exposure.

To address those risks, some owners are transferring their high-value assets into a newly formed single-member limited liability company (LLC). While an LLC can offer legitimate benefits—like protection, privacy, and estate planning—it’s also a potential tax trap if done incorrectly. Here’s how to approach this strategy with care.

Why Use an LLC for Appreciated Assets?

A sole-member LLC is a business entity with one owner, disregarded for federal tax purposes but recognized under state law. It can serve as a wrapper around valuable assets, offering several benefits:

1. Asset Protection

An LLC creates a legal boundary between the owner’s personal and business assets. If the LLC is sued—over a disputed artwork or a car accident—your home and personal bank accounts may be protected. This is especially useful when holding volatile or high-liability assets like cryptocurrency or classic vehicles.

2. Privacy

Some states, like Wyoming, Nevada, Florida, and Texas, allow the formation of LLCs with minimal public disclosure, helping shield the owner’s identity. This is particularly useful for Bitcoin holders (given blockchain transparency) or collectors who prefer to stay out of public databases.

3. Estate Planning

Transferring assets into an LLC allows for gifting membership interests to heirs, often at a discounted valuation. For instance, a $1 million painting held through an LLC might be appraised at $650,000 due to restrictions on transferability—potentially reducing gift or estate taxes.

4. Tax Efficiency

By default, a sole-member LLC is a “disregarded entity,” meaning income and losses pass through to the owner’s personal return. The LLC may also deduct relevant business expenses—such as secure crypto storage, art insurance, or vehicle maintenance—where appropriate.

Basic Steps to Transfer Appreciated Assets to an LLC

1. Form the LLC

Choose a state that offers strong legal protections and favorable fees. Wyoming, Nevada, Texas, and Florida are common choices for non-residents due to privacy, low costs, and absence of state income tax. File Articles of Organization, obtain an EIN from the IRS, and open a separate bank account (preferably in that state).

Important Note: If you are not a resident of the state where you form the LLC, you must establish a legitimate nexus—such as using a local registered agent, maintaining storage, having an office, or transacting business in that state. Without a clear nexus, state authorities (including DMVs) may question the legitimacy of registering a vehicle there. Some states aggressively pursue out-of-state registrants when they suspect tax avoidance.

2. Draft an Operating Agreement

This internal document isn’t always required, but it’s smart practice—especially for estate planning or asset transfers. Define control, transfer provisions, and succession plans to avoid probate (see TCoL article here). Get your LLC membership interest into your revocable trust (see TCoL article here).

3. Value the Assets

Obtain a fair market value (FMV) at the time of transfer. For crypto, document exchange pricing. For art or vehicles, use qualified appraisers. This establishes a defensible basis for tax reporting and insurance.

4. Transfer Ownership

Move the assets into the LLC (but not before reading about the pitfalls below):

• Bitcoin: Send coins to a wallet owned and secured by the LLC.

• Art or Cars: Execute a bill of sale or assignment. Update titles and insurance. For vehicles, retitle through the state DMV. Ensure the new owner of record is the LLC.

5. Update Insurance and Contracts

Personal policies often don’t cover business-owned assets. Switch to commercial insurance and update any storage or maintenance agreements.

6. Maintain Formal Separation

Preserve the liability shield by keeping business and personal finances separate. Document all asset transfers, maintain accurate books, and file required state reports.

Tax Consequences: The Hidden Costs

Despite being disregarded for federal tax purposes, transferring appreciated assets to a sole-member LLC may trigger unexpected taxes.

1. Capital Gains Tax

If the IRS determines that the transfer is a taxable event—akin to a sale—you may owe capital gains tax. For example, moving Bitcoin bought at $10,000 into an LLC when it’s worth $100,000 could trigger a $90,000 gain. Art and vehicles, categorized as collectibles, are taxed at up to 28% federally, higher than typical long-term gains. Add 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax, plus state rates (e.g., 13.3% in California), and the bill climbs fast.

2. Transfer Taxes and State Rules

Some states impose taxes or fees on transfers—even when there's no sale. For example:

• Florida may impose documentary stamp tax on certain transfers of interest.

• California charges an $800 minimum LLC tax annually.

3. Due-on-Sale Clauses

If a financed vehicle or painting is transferred into an LLC, the lender may call the loan due under a “due-on-sale” clause. That could trigger a forced refinance or immediate repayment. Or, simply an amendment to the loan and a personal guarantee. Always ask your lender.

Mitigate Tax Risk

• Capital Contribution, Not Sale: Structure the transfer as a capital contribution. If there’s no change in beneficial ownership and the LLC remains a disregarded entity, the IRS typically won’t treat it as a sale.

• Avoid Business Use: If the LLC begins using the assets for income-generating activity (e.g., renting artwork), the IRS may apply different rules, increasing scrutiny.

• On A Project Like This, ALWAYS consult a Tax Advisor and Attorney: Ensure the transfer is compliant with both IRS treatment and state-specific tax and other laws. Poor structuring could erase gains, benefits of the LLC formation, and invite unwanted tax or legal trouble.

Transferring highly appreciated Bitcoin, art, or collector vehicles into a sole-member LLC can offer legitimate advantages—but only if executed correctly. The legal process is relatively simple, but the tax landscape is full of hidden traps. Understand your state’s laws, avoid triggering a disguised sale, and document everything with care.

As with most planning, what protects you in court or with creditors may be the very thing that costs you at tax time. Navigate both sides.

And never transfer a million-dollar painting (or anything else) to your LLC without first obtaining an opinion from a licensed tax professional whether it’ll cost you $280,000 in federal tax.

Dear TCoL: Trying And Not Succeeding To Involve My Son In The Family Business

Question: I’ve tried just about everything to get my son involved in our family business. He is in his last year of college and wants help to start his own business. I like it but don’t like the fact that he keeps turning me down. Should I help?

Answer: Maybe. Have you tried offering to commit to help with the new startup (I’m assuming that he wants capital or a loan) in return for him to work with you for six months or a year at the family business, somewhat like an apprenticeship? Seems worth a try, especially if he hasn’t formulated a sound business plan. You might get the standard objection that the market is moving too fast in his space and he can’t delay. That typically is not the case (even if he thinks so) and an extra six months or year honing a great plan and product is time well spent.

If you can’t make headway with the apprentice idea, I would suggest you help him if you can afford it and the plan and product are sound. If he succeeds, great! If he doesn’t, great! He will learn from it, and you will not have alienated him by continuing to push too hard to join the family business. Best of luck!

Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!