Good morning!

-TCoL

Missed our last feature article? Recognizing When Your Business Has Outgrown You

The DTC beauty category is crowded. To break through, Jennifer Aniston’s brand LolaVie, worked with Roku Ads Manager to easily set up, test, and optimize CTV ad creatives. The campaign helped drive a big lift in sales and customer growth, helping LolaVie break through in the crowded beauty category.

Learn more

You search your own business name one day and find someone else using it. Or a client sends you a screenshot of a logo that looks a lot like yours on a competitor’s website. The reaction is usually outrage followed quickly by uncertainty: what can you actually do, and where do you start?

The answer depends on what protection you have in place. But even owners without a registered trademark have real options, and the path forward in both situations is more structured than most people expect. Before anything else, build your record.

Whatever path you eventually take, it begins here. Take screenshots of the infringing use with the URL and date visible. Save copies of any communications. Note where the infringement appears, whether on a website, a social media account, a marketplace listing, or product packaging, and identify when you first became aware of it. If you can establish when the other party started using the mark, document that too.

This record is the foundation of everything that follows. A cease and desist letter without documentation is just a letter. An attorney cannot help you effectively without it. If the matter reaches a platform complaint system or a courtroom, the strength of your case will rest significantly on what you preserved and when.

In the United States, trademark rights are built on use, not registration. If you have been operating under a business name or using a logo consistently in commerce, you already have what the law calls common law trademark rights. Those rights are real, but they are limited to the geographic area where you have actually been doing business. A competitor using your name in a distant market, with no overlap in customers, may not be infringing your rights at all, even when the situation feels plainly unfair.

Common law rights give you standing to send a cease and desist letter, negotiate a resolution, and pursue litigation if necessary. Unregistered mark owners can also bring claims in federal court under Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act, which covers unfair competition and false designation of origin, though they cannot bring the stronger registered trademark infringement claim available under Section 1114. The practical difference is that federal claims under Section 43(a) require more proof and carry fewer presumptions than a claim backed by a federal registration.

If the infringement is causing real harm and you do not yet have a registration, filing a trademark application with the USPTO as soon as possible is worth doing alongside any enforcement effort. If your application matures into a registration, it will establish constructive use nationwide from your filing date, which can be decisive against anyone who began using a similar mark after you filed.

A registered trademark changes your position considerably. It creates a legal presumption that you own the mark nationwide, allows you to bring a registered trademark infringement claim in federal court under Section 1114 of the Lanham Act, and shifts the burden of proof to the other party to rebut your ownership. It also opens access to platform enforcement tools that are largely unavailable to unregistered owners.

If someone is using your mark online, on social media, in a marketplace listing, or through a domain name, most major platforms have built-in IP complaint systems. Instagram, Facebook, Amazon, Etsy, and Shopify all allow registered trademark owners to report infringement directly, and many platforms will act on a valid complaint within days, though response times vary. You will need your federal registration number and clear documentation of the infringing use. This route is faster and cheaper than litigation and should generally be your first move when the infringement is occurring on a third-party platform.

Whether you have a federal registration or common law rights, a cease and desist letter is typically the first formal step in a name or logo dispute. It is a written demand that the other party stop using your mark, and it does two things: it puts the infringer on notice that you are aware of the situation and serious about it, and it creates a paper trail that matters if the matter escalates.

Most infringers, particularly small businesses that adopted a similar name without conducting a proper search, will comply when they receive a well-drafted letter from an attorney. The cases that do not resolve at this stage tend to be ones where the other party believes they have prior rights, or where they are deliberately trading on your reputation.

A cease and desist letter should identify the mark you own, describe the specific infringing use, state the legal basis for your claim, demand that the use stop by a stated date, and make clear what follows if it does not. Having an attorney draft it is worth the cost. A letter on counsel’s letterhead carries more weight, and an improperly drafted demand can create problems of its own.

If the infringer ignores the letter or refuses to comply, your options are litigation in state or federal court, or, for online infringement, escalation through platform enforcement channels. Where copyright issues are also present, a Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) takedown notice to the platform or hosting provider may be available, though the DMCA is a copyright statute and does not directly address trademark infringement. Litigation is expensive and slow, and for most small business disputes it is a last resort. Whether it makes sense depends on how much the infringement is actually costing you, how strong your rights are, and the practical realities of pursuing the other party.

One thing worth knowing: allowing documented, ongoing infringement to continue without response can weaken your rights over time. Courts recognize that a mark owner who fails to police their mark risks having those rights eroded. You do not need to pursue every minor case, but systematic infringement that you ignore on the record is a problem.

None of this requires a lawsuit to be effective. A well-documented cease and desist letter resolves most name and logo disputes before they go any further. What it does require is that you move quickly, keep your records clean, and understand what you actually have to work with, whether or not you ever filed a trademark.

If you have not yet registered your trademark, that is the logical next step. Your name and logo are worth protecting before someone else forces the issue.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Trademark rights vary based on jurisdiction, registration status, and the specific facts of each situation. Consult a licensed attorney before taking action in any trademark dispute.

Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!