When You Need an Appraisal for Your Business

Good Morning!

1. Feature: When You Need an Appraisal for Your Business (4 min)

2. From the Archive:

   • Growing Quietly with Customers That Keep Coming Back for More

   • You're Talking to the Wrong Crowd

-TCoL

Missed our last feature article? The Silent Fees Eating Your LLC Alive

Every business owner eventually reaches a moment when guesswork is no longer enough. Maybe you are planning a sale. Maybe a partner wants to cash out. Maybe a lender wants a documented value before extending credit. Each situation calls for a different type of appraisal. Some are quick. Some are detailed. All benefit from preparation.

This article explains the main types of appraisals an SMB owner can obtain and when each one makes sense. It also explains how private equity thinks about valuation and why their preferred approach affects the multiples you hear discussed in the market. Finally, it covers how to prepare so the process is smooth, and the result reflects the real strength of your business.

Start with the Simplest Option

Many owners begin with a book value appraisal. It measures assets minus liabilities and reflects the equity shown on your balance sheet. The calculation is simple and often handled internally.

You can make this approach far more useful by asking your CPA to prepare the calculation and place it on their letterhead. The added formality reduces questions about the method and provides a neutral document for planning and compensation. It does not create the authority of a formal valuation, but it improves confidence in the figures.

Tracking book value annually is one of the most practical habits an owner can build. It supplies clear and understandable information about performance and growth. It gives a baseline reference for enterprise value in asset heavy businesses and a simple benchmark for everyone involved in planning. Most lenders and managers understand it without long explanation.

Many companies also use book value as part of bonus plans for owners and senior leadership. When paired with profit or cash flow targets it supports a fair system tied to measurable progress. It helps people think like owners because part of their compensation reflects long term improvement in the firm.

Book value has limits. It does not measure customer loyalty, market position, technology, or earnings power. For most SMBs it should be treated as a baseline reference, not a measure of true market value.

Move to a More Practical Measurement

When owners want something more informative than book value, they often look at a market-based appraisal. This approach compares your business to similar businesses that have sold. It is a useful way to understand what buyers have recently paid. Owners use it when preparing for a sale or when considering an investor who wants to enter at a fair price.

A market-based appraisal draws from actual transactions. It considers your revenue, margins, customer mix, size, and industry conditions. The result is more connected to the real world than a simple balance sheet calculation.

Market data can be uneven. Some industries have few reported transactions. Some businesses are too unique for easy comparison. Still, many owners find this approach gives them a helpful and practical sense of value without requiring a full independent valuation.

Understand the Income Approach

Another option many owners use, outside a formal valuation engagement, is the income-based appraisal. It estimates the present value of future earnings and is most useful for businesses with steady and predictable cash flow.

This approach requires several years of financial history. It separates normal earnings from one-time events. It considers risks specific to the business and the industry. The appraiser then applies a rate that reflects those risks. In a full independent valuation this method is usually one of the core tools used.

Owners turn to the income approach during partner buyouts, equity grants for key employees, and loan applications where lenders want clear insight into future earning power. The strength of this method is its focus on cash flow. The weakness is the judgment involved. Two experienced appraisers can reach different conclusions about future earnings or the multiple to apply. Even so, it remains central to many valuation discussions.

How Private Equity Thinks About Value

Private equity buyers often rely on multiples of adjusted EBITDA when negotiating a purchase price. EBITDA stands for earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. Adjusted EBITDA removes unusual or owner specific expenses, so the number reflects the true earning capacity of the business under new ownership.

Buyers prefer this measure because it focuses on cash generation. It also allows easier comparison across companies in the same industry. A business with strong adjusted EBITDA and consistent growth will command a higher multiple because investors can see a clear path to returns.

Multiples vary widely. In some years technology enabled service companies receive premium prices because investors are pursuing those sectors. In other years industrial, logistics, or health care businesses attract aggressive multiples because private equity firms are competing for reliable cash flow. Valuation trends shift with investor appetite and available capital. A business that earns six times adjusted EBITDA in one market might earn nine or ten times in another simply because demand has changed.

Owners considering a sale to private equity should understand this dynamic. The business itself matters. The market cycle matters as well. Strong preparation and clear financial reporting position you to benefit when multiples rise in your industry.

Know When You Need a Formal Independent Appraisal

At some point an owner may need a full independent valuation. For most SMBs this is the most comprehensive form of appraisal. It is performed by an independent professional who follows established valuation standards. They analyze financial statements, management practices, competitive conditions, and legal documents. They use multiple methods and reconcile the results.

A formal independent valuation is often used for estate and gift tax filings. It is common in disputes involving ownership. It is frequently required in leveraged transactions when lenders want assurance that the price is fair. It is standard in larger acquisitions when buyers and sellers need a defensible value.

This type of appraisal takes more time and costs more than other approaches. The benefit is credibility. It gives you a report that stands up to scrutiny and helps resolve disagreements before they turn into problems.

How to Prepare for Any Appraisal

Preparation makes every appraisal easier. Begin by gathering three to five years of financial statements. Make sure they are accurate and updated. Prepare a list of major assets including equipment, vehicles, property, intellectual property, customer relationships, and key contracts. Identify meaningful changes in the business such as new products, supplier changes, or shifts in customer concentration. These items help the appraiser understand your situation.

Be ready to explain your market. You know your competitors and the conditions shaping your industry. Your insight matters. A capable appraiser uses your perspective to make better assumptions.

A Final Thought for Owners

An appraisal is a tool. A simple book value estimate supports planning. A market-based comparison helps prepare for buyer conversations. An income-based approach strengthens partner decisions. A private equity style cash flow/EBITDA analysis shows how investors think about your company. A full independent appraisal protects you when the stakes are high.

Owners who prepare well often learn something important about their business. The insight alone can be worth the effort. Understanding value is one of the most practical steps you can take for your company’s future.

Sponsor Spotlight

TaxElm: Want to keep more of what you earn? Our tax strategy system helps entrepreneurs and business owners legally reduce their tax burden. Download our free Tax Savings Starter Kit or book a discovery call with Matt Grimmer from our team.

Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!