In partnership with
Good morning!
Feature: Your First Employee vs. Your First Contractor (4 min)
From the Archive:
-TCoL
Missed our last feature article? How to Pay Yourself Without Inviting IRS Scrutiny
How Jennifer Anniston’s LolaVie brand grew sales 40% with CTV ads
For its first CTV campaign, Jennifer Aniston’s DTC haircare brand LolaVie had a few non-negotiables. The campaign had to be simple. It had to demonstrate measurable impact. And it had to be full-funnel.
LolaVie used Roku Ads Manager to test and optimize creatives — reaching millions of potential customers at all stages of their purchase journeys. Roku Ads Manager helped the brand convey LolaVie’s playful voice while helping drive omnichannel sales across both ecommerce and retail touchpoints.
The campaign included an Action Ad overlay that let viewers shop directly from their TVs by clicking OK on their Roku remote. This guided them to the website to buy LolaVie products.
Discover how Roku Ads Manager helped LolaVie drive big sales and customer growth with self-serve TV ads.
The DTC beauty category is crowded. To break through, Jennifer Anniston’s brand LolaVie, worked with Roku Ads Manager to easily set up, test, and optimize CTV ad creatives. The campaign helped drive a big lift in sales and customer growth, helping LolaVie break through in the crowded beauty category.
You can label a subcontractor relationship what you like, but for federal employment tax purposes the IRS classifies it under their rules based on the facts. You choose how you will run the relationship. The classification follows the facts.
For employment tax purposes, the IRS starts with a simple premise: an “employee” includes anyone who is an employee under usual common-law rules.
That is the trap for many first-time hires. Owners intend to bring on “a contractor,” then manage the person like an employee because the work is important, time-sensitive, and close to the business. The paperwork says contractor. The day-to-day looks like an employee. Over time, the day-to-day governs.
IRS information you should use
IRS Publication 1779 is one of the clearer IRS explainers for business owners because it organizes the analysis into three buckets:
behavioral control
financial control
relationship of the parties
Across its materials, the IRS repeats the same idea: the substance of the relationship matters more than the label you put on it.
If you want a single sentence to remember, it is this: the more you retain the right to direct and control how the work is done, the more you move toward “employee.”
The misclassification trap, in plain English
Here is how it typically happens.
You hire a “contractor” to help with marketing, operations, dispatch, customer support, bookkeeping, or sales development. At first, the work is project-based. Then the person becomes essential. You add recurring weekly tasks. You ask them to attend team meetings. You give them a company email address. You begin training them in your preferred process.
Training is not a neutral fact. IRS guidance treats training about procedures and methods as strong evidence of an employee relationship, because it shows you want the job done in a particular way.
A practical “first hire” decision test
Before you decide on “contractor,” answer these questions as if you were explaining them to a skeptical auditor:
Will I set the person’s hours, or require real-time availability most days?
Will I supervise the details of how they do the work, not just what gets delivered?
Will I provide ongoing training about my methods or business?
Is the work a continuing role with no defined end date?
Is the work a key part of what we sell or deliver as a business?
If you are answering “yes” to several of these questions, you are not purchasing an outside service. You are staffing an employee.
The deeper law under the hood
You will sometimes see references to a “20-factor test.” That comes from Revenue Ruling 87-41, which the IRS describes as an analytical approach drawn from cases and rulings.
You do not need to memorize 20 factors, and no single factor controls. You need to understand what they tend to measure: control, independence, and whether the worker is genuinely running their own business.
If you want more detail beyond Publication 1779, the IRS directs employers to its employment tax guidance in Publication 15-A and related materials for more specialized analysis.
Get tools that work as hard as you do.
The Co. Letter Premium gives you access to over 20 professionally prepared templates that cost hundreds from an attorney. Protect your LLC, save time on paperwork, and avoid unnecessary legal fees.
Nine practical rules for using a contractor
These subcontractor rules align with the IRS’s control-and-independence framework, and they echo basic contracting discipline: clear scope and clear expectations.
Write a scope of work that reads like a deliverables list, not a job description.
If it reads like “duties include…,” you are already slipping toward an employee frame.Pay for outputs, not attendance.
Hourly pay is not determinative, but if you pay hourly and also control the schedule, the overall picture becomes clearer.Do not train them in your methods unless you are calling them an employee.
Ongoing training is strong evidence of employee status in IRS guidance.Let them use their own tools and workflows when feasible.
The more you require your internal systems, your internal process, and your internal supervision, the harder it is to maintain the contractor story.Avoid exclusivity.
A contractor who cannot work for others does not appear independent.Keep the relationship project-bounded when you can.
An open-ended, indefinite engagement often looks like ongoing employment.Keep them out of your internal org chart.
Company email, company titles, and “team member” presentations are not decisive, but they rarely help the contractor position.Paper the tax side correctly.
Contractors typically provide a Form W-9 so you can issue a Form 1099-NEC when required (generally for payments of $600 or more in the course of a trade or business, subject to exceptions). Employees complete Form W-4 and receive a Form W-2. If you treat someone like an employee but run contractor paperwork, you are creating a clear record of the mismatch.Decide in advance what will trigger conversion.
If the contractor becomes a core, ongoing role where you need control and continuity, move to employment rather than drifting into it.
A useful rule of thumb: if your “contractor” needs permission to take a vacation, you should re-check your classification.
When to convert your contractor into an employee
Conversion is not an admission of wrongdoing. Often it is simply a recognition that the facts have changed.
Convert when you cross these lines:
the work becomes a continuing seat, not a defined project
you need consistent hours and availability
you are training the person in your methods
the person is economically dependent on you in practice
you are integrating the person into the core operations you sell
If you are converting, do it cleanly. Use an offer letter, set up payroll, and treat the change as a business upgrade: clarity, compliance, and continuity.
What to do when you are unsure
The IRS provides a formal mechanism to request a status determination: Form SS-8.
Before you file it, read the instructions carefully. The IRS explains that information on Form SS-8 may be shared with the firm, worker, or payer to assist in the determination process, and that both sides may be contacted. If you do not want that level of disclosure, do not file.
Form SS-8 is a tool, but it is not a private one.
The bottom line
Your first “contractor” often becomes your first employee in everything but name. The IRS does not grade the name. It evaluates the relationship.
If you want the flexibility of contractors, structure the engagement agreement like a true outside service: defined scope, deliverables, independence, and limited control over how the work gets done. If the role requires training, scheduling, and integration into your core operations, hire an employee and move on with more certainty.
Editor’s note: This article describes the federal employment tax framework; states and other agencies may apply different tests. This is general information, not tax advice. Before classifying or reclassifying a worker, confirm the implications with your CPA.
Have an interesting business question and need a free bit of advice? Send your question to [email protected]. No confidential info, please!
